Bakery · Silkstone Common, Penistone
Cottage Bakery Shop Menu & Prices
Planning what to order at Cottage Bakery Shop? This menu gathers the bakes you are most likely to find at a bakery like this, with indicative prices for 2026.
Indicative menu. Items and prices are typical for this style of bakery and are not supplied by Cottage Bakery Shop. Always ask staff about allergens.
Savouries & Pasties
- Sausage rollPopular £1.35 Seasoned pork sausage meat wrapped in golden, flaky puff pastry and glazed with egg.
- Pork pie £3.70 Hand-raised hot-water crust filled with coarsely seasoned pork and savoury jelly.
- Minced beef and onion pie £2.90 Seasoned minced beef and onion in proper gravy beneath a shortcrust lid.
- Chicken bake £2.60 Chicken pieces in a creamy white sauce, baked inside crisp, buttery puff pastry.
- Vegetable pastyV £2.40 Carrot, peas, potato and swede, lightly spiced and baked in crimped shortcrust.
- Sausage, bean and cheese melt £2.85 Sausage, baked beans and melted cheese tucked into a golden puff pastry slice.
- Steak bakePopular £2.00 Tender chunks of beef in rich peppery gravy, encased in layers of crisp puff pastry.
- Steak and kidney pie £3.95 Slow-cooked beef and kidney in thick gravy under a short, buttery pastry lid.
Breads & Rolls
- Soft white rolls (pack of 6)V £2.00 Pillowy white baps, perfect for bacon butties and packed lunches.
- White bloomerPopularVVG £3.10 Crusty, slashed white loaf with a soft, open crumb, baked fresh every morning.
- Wholemeal tin loafPopularVVG £2.10 Wholesome stoneground wholemeal bread baked in a tin for easy, even slicing.
- Split tinVVG £2.10 Classic white tin loaf with a distinctive split top and golden crust.
- Fruited teacakes (pack of 4)V £2.10 Soft, lightly spiced teacakes packed with currants, best split and toasted.
- Granary loafVVG £3.10 Malted brown loaf with chewy wheat flakes and a gently nutty flavour.
- Farmhouse whiteVVG £2.80 Deep, floured white loaf with a soft crumb that makes excellent toast.
Sandwiches & Filled Rolls
- Egg mayonnaise sandwichV £2.60 Free-range egg mayonnaise with cress on soft malted bread.
- Cheese and pickle sandwichV £3.55 Mature Cheddar and tangy brown pickle layered on farmhouse white.
- BLT sandwich £4.40 Smoky back bacon, crunchy lettuce and ripe tomato on lightly buttered bread.
- Ham salad rollPopular £2.80 Thick-cut ham with lettuce, tomato and cucumber in a soft white roll.
- Hot bacon rollPopular £2.95 Grilled back bacon in a soft floured bap, served warm with your choice of sauce.
- Coronation chicken sandwich £3.65 Chicken in a mild, fruity curried mayonnaise on soft white bread.
- Tuna mayo and cucumber baguette £3.30 Flaked tuna in mayonnaise with crunchy cucumber in a fresh white baguette.
Cream Cakes & Buns
- Cream sliceV £1.80 Layers of puff pastry, jam and cream finished with a crisp icing top.
- Belgian bunV £2.05 Sweet sultana swirl topped with white icing and a bright glacé cherry.
- Cream hornV £2.20 Crisp puff pastry cone filled with jam and a generous swirl of fresh cream.
- Jam doughnutV £1.35 Classic ring-free doughnut rolled in sugar with a raspberry jam centre.
- Fresh cream doughnutPopularV £2.15 Sugared yeast doughnut split and filled with whipped cream and strawberry jam.
- Vanilla custard sliceV £2.40 Thick set vanilla custard between puff pastry layers with feathered white icing.
- Iced finger bunPopularV £0.90 Soft, sweet finger roll topped with a thick layer of white or pink icing.
- Chelsea bunV £2.00 Coiled, sticky currant bun glazed with sugar syrup and a hint of spice.
Traybakes, Tarts & Biscuits
- Viennese whirlV £1.50 Melt-in-the-mouth piped biscuits sandwiched with buttercream and raspberry jam.
- Golden syrup flapjackPopularV £2.45 Chewy oat bar baked with butter and golden syrup until caramelised at the edges.
- Bakewell tartVN £2.20 Shortcrust tart with raspberry jam, almond frangipane and a cherry on white icing.
- Lemon drizzle sliceV £2.10 Moist lemon sponge soaked in sharp lemon syrup with a crunchy sugar crust.
- Fruit sconeV £1.95 Light, buttery scone dotted with sultanas, lovely with jam and clotted cream.
- Rocky roadV £2.85 Chocolate, crushed biscuit, marshmallow and cherries set into a chunky square.
- Eccles cakeV £2.10 Flaky pastry round packed with buttery spiced currants and sprinkled with sugar.
- Gingerbread manV £1.60 Crisp, warmly spiced gingerbread figure with iced buttons and a smile.
Ordering tips for Cottage Bakery Shop
- Arrive early for the widest choice – bread and the most popular bakes often sell out by lunchtime.
- Allergen information must be available on request under UK law – ask before you buy if you have an allergy.
Make a morning of it
All in PenistoneOther bakeries near Cottage Bakery Shop
Cake Shop
Blackburn's Cakes
Store Rear Of, 77 Pitt Street West, Barnsley S70 1BN
Hours not listedHygiene 5/53.1 mi